Obama Fires Advisor Who Called Clinton a "Monster"
Obama foreign policy advisor Samantha Power, a professor at Harvard and a Pulitzer Prize winner, has resigned after giving a newspaper interview in which she bad-mouthed Hillary Clinton:
"We f***d up in Ohio," Power told the Scotsman newspaper ..."In Ohio, they are obsessed and Hillary is going to town on it, because she knows Ohio's the only place they can win," Power was quoted as saying.
"She is a monster, too -- that is off the record -- she is stooping to anything," Power said.
"You just look at her and think 'Ergh.'"
Power apologized, but the Clinton campaign pounced all over it, really piling it on:
"Personal attacks are not the way to convince voters that you are capable of being the president of the United States," said congresswoman Nita Lowey, who called the drama a "test" for Obama."We call on Senator Obama to make it clear that Samantha Power should not be part of this campaign."
Another Clinton backer, congresswoman Debbie Wasserman Shultz added: "going down in the gutter like that and engaging in grade school name calling is distasteful and inappropriate."
Within hours Power had resigned and Obama spokesman Bill Burton said the candidate "decries such characterizations which have no place in this campaign."
This comes one day after the Clinton campaign deflected Obama's call for disclosure of Clinton's tax returns and donors to the Clinton presidential library by comparing Obama to Whitewater special prosecutor Ken Starr. No one called for the spokesman, Howard Wolfson, to resign. Power should have satisfied herself with comparing Clinton to an actual person, Karl Rove perhaps, because that's acceptable and "monster" isn't.
When my misbehaving brothers and I were little our parents sometimes called us "little monsters." We called on them to resign but it didn't do any good.
UPDATE: In my initial draft of this post I went on to compare the Clinton campaign's response to classic GOP strategy under Karl Rove: seize on a word or phrase that sounds bad, feign over-the-top outrage, demand an apology, generate a bad news cycle for the opposition, all completely unrelated to the issues. I decided that was too over-the-top, but I see that Josh Marshall and his readers are all over it:
Can't believe that Samantha Power actually resigned. This is the type of phony "controversy" the GOP/Karl Rove uses to their advantage. Josh famously called it the "bitch slap" theory of politics, and Clinton is using the same playbook. Obama needed to send a signal that these types of fake outrages won't play, but by her quick resigntation, the bitch slap is alive and well.Depressing.
Indeed.







but is there any justification for what she said, on the record?
I agree with nearly everything you've written here in this post Jeff, but is any of it justification for what Power said in her interview?
No
There is no justification for the using the word "monster." It's bad. But is it bad enough for the Reuters headline referring to the advisor as "mudslinging"? (How "mud?") It is bad enough for the Clinton campaign's show of outrage? That's the question, I guess - not whether there is justification for what she said, but whether the response was proportional.
By the way, did you catch that she said "that is off the record" but the newspaper printed it anyway? It ought to matter that she didn't intend the word for publication.
I see what you said now
You don't think that her after-the-fact instruction of the word being off the record counts. Fair enough, perhaps, for journalistic purposes, but I think it should mitigate the offense that Power thought she could remove the ill-considered word from the record.
It may well be that
It may well be that the Obama campaign is using the Clinton reaction as a pretext for getting rid of Power who also has been shown in tv footage saying in another interview that Obama will not follow policy toward Iraq outlined in his campaign speeches. He has already gotten caught on a discrepancy with another of his spokesmen between what he says about NAFTA in his speeches and what the spokesman was saying he really meant when talking with authorities in Canada. But the Pied Piper has a splendid song. If he ran with Hillary as vice president and she made him get down to work and really become the leader he potentially could be, the Democrats could keep the White House for four terms.
Had to pass this on
Saw this comment on reddit and had to pass it on:
"Obama should make a statement: Hillary Clinton is not a monster, as far as I know."
HIllary is kinda lying in the bed she made.
Clever!
Good clever suggestion, Cindy. :)
yes that would be great
Yes as far as i know she is not a monster.
Samantha Power is a brilliant woman - and it is too bad that she slipped - but she has apologized, and resigned. I think this is a sad loss for the Obama campaign - and not one they are secretly happy about.
Geraldine Ferraro (who was really mainly on the ticket as VP because she was a woman - not because she was the most qualified running mate, and who's husband's subsequently exposed connections to the mafia really made winning the white house that year impossible) - should apologize at the the very least. The Clinton's should take some of their own medicine and ask her to resign.
For her to claim that her remarks are being attacked because she is white is patently absurd.
Ferraro : conscientious and honest
Ferraro seems to have anticipated certain of her detractors. In the speech she gave during which she attributed Obama's success to his being African American, she also attributed her former vice-presidential candidacy to her being a woman. Her analysis of voting behavior being racially influenced was irrefutably demonstrated in Mississippi. She's calling it as she sees it and it's pretty easy to see at this point.
After receiving a lot of hate mail from Obama supporters, she made a statement on tv during which she made a few key points. First, she said she WAS NOT A SPOKESWOMAN for the Clinton campaign but was solely involved in fund-raising. Second, she said that if it became necessary due to pressure from the Obama campaign for her to officially resign, she would do so but that she WOULD CONTINUE--UNOFFICIALLY--TO RAISE FUNDS for the Clinton campaign. Third, she stated that -- despite all the unfair accusations of her being a racist -- she WOULD RAISE FUNDS FOR OBAMA if he ended up being chosen as the Democratic candidate.
She certainly is a cut above certain supporters in terms of political consciousness.