Former county commissioner Phil Heimlich (R) has withdrawn from the GOP primary, saying that victory is not possible because of the recent endorsement of Rep. Jean Schmidt (R-Loveland) by the Hamilton County GOP and the entry of rival challenger State Rep. Joe Brinkman (R-Mount Lookout) into the primary. Although the GOP primary will continue to be entertaining because Schmidt and Brinkman are both
embarrassments controversial figures, Heimlich seemed to be the stronger challenger, so this development appears to wrap things up for Schmidt. I'm guessing that they are celebrating in the headquarters of the Democratic candidates, Victoria Wulsin (D-Indian Hill) and Steve Black (D-Indian Hill).
What's happening on the hustings:
OH-01: Chabot Chastised About SCHIP - David reports that Americans United for Change is running an ad slamming Rep. Steve Chabot (R-Westwood) over his votes against expanding SCHIP. Another veto override attempt is expected today.
OH-02: Black Investments Questioned Again - On the heels of a report that Steve Black (D-Indian Hill) criticized Halliburton for war profiteering in his first mailer but recently held Halliburton stock (a charge that the Black campaign rebutted by indicating that Black had disposed of the Halliburton stock at a loss when he discovered it among his assets) comes another, similar allegation: that Black and his family own substantial holdings in pharmaceutical, insurance, and oil companies while stating in his literature that "It's wrong that drug companies and insurance companies make millions while middle-class families can't afford health care" and "Investing in clean, renewable energy and reducing global warming starts with getting tough on oil companies." I have contacted the Black campaign for a response.
UPDATE: Steve Black's campaign manager Dan Herkert has issued a a statement that does not deny that the candidate or his family holds pharmaceutical, insurance or oil company stocks, but instead calls the charge "another attempt" by Victoria Wulsin (D-Indian Hill) "to divert attention from the real issues in this campaign – creating jobs, affordable healthcare, and responsibly ending the war in Iraq." Herkert says that Black "firmly believes in full disclosure and has gone above and beyond the requirements set forth by the law," reporting "each and every stock that he owns or has sold in the past year, as well as disclosing each stock that is held by his family’s trust and within his IRA," but charges that Wulsin's financial disclosures have been deficient:
“The real question here is why Vic Wulsin had to amend her House Financial Disclosure Statement and why she failed to report all of her investments in the first place. In her first disclosure statement dated 5/13/07, Wulsin listed investment holdings valued between $505,010.00 and $1,200,000.00. In her amended filing dated 12/26/07, she listed investment holdings valued between $1,260,035.00 and $2,655,00.00. Why were these investments not reported initially? Either Wulsin does not take the concept of full disclosure seriously, or she apparently tried to hide something. She needs to explain to voters why she disregarded financial disclosure requirements and explain why she had to so dramatically amend her filing.”
Meanwhile, Howard Wilkinson reports on Politics Extra that the Clermont County Democratic Party will hold a straw poll on February 9th that will be an important sign of where things stand in the Democratic primary.
OH-07: Wyderski Online; Conner on Challengers - Dr. Richard Wyderski (D-Beavercreek) has a new campaign site, which at this point amounts to a single-page biographical sketch rendered in an eye-popping, action-comic graphic style. His slogan is "We Need s Doctor In The House" and his bio is almost entirely about his career in health care, which is very distinguished. He is also a Clinton delegate to the Democratic National Convention.
Meanwhile, repeat candidate Bill Connor (D-Beavercreek) has added a disparaging appraisal of his five Democratic adversaries to his web site. All are portrayed as insufficiently active in Democratic politics and/or insufficiently engaged with the issues, although the jury appears be out with respect to Wyderski and attorney Sharen Neuhardt (D-Yellow Springs) whose websites don't appear to be in final form. All but Jack Null (D-Fairborn) bear the heavy burden of lacking military service, and Null is said to be distributing an issues sheet that marks him as a Republican/Libertarian (make Bush tax cuts permanent, legalize drugs and prostitution). An entertaining peek at Conner's view of the primary.
OH-10: Cimperman Hits Airwaves - The campaign of Joe Cimperman (D-Cleveland) announced that he will begin airing the TV ad embedded on this blog yesterday on broadcast and cable television in the greater Cleveland area today, making him the first candidate in this race to hit the airwaves with paid media. Cimperman has raised by far the largest amount of campaign cash in this race - over $226,000 in a single month. Sabrina Eaton reports on Openers that Rep. Kucinich has a video on his web site asking for money to air TV ads in response.
OH-12: Fund-Raiser for Goodwin - Joann Paradis, George and Sue Shellabarger, Short North Progressives, Mid-Town South Progressives, Franklin County Young Democrats, and Stonewall Democrats of Central Ohio will host a wine and cheese reception for Russ Goodwin (D-Columbus) today from 7:00 to 9:00 p.m. at the Brewer's Yard Club House, 100 W. Frankfort Square, in the Brewery District. Suggested donation is $25.00 (Young Democrats $20.00). RSVP to RSVPforGoodwin@gmail.com.
OH-16: Race Ranked as Top Turnover Propect - I missed this at the time, but last Friday prognosticator Chris Cillizza of the Washington Post listed OH-16 as the most likely pickup in the U.S. House by either party.
OH-18: Space Calls For SCHIP Veto Override - A statement from Rep. Zack Space (D-Dover) on the U.S. House vote expected to occur today: “This vital legislation will guarantee that 10 million children will have health insurance coverage no matter what happens to the economy, their parent’s employment, or the cost of care. We simply cannot allow our children to go without the health coverage they need simply to fulfill the President’s misguided political whims. Overriding this veto will send yet another clear message to the President that we need this program now more than ever. As our nation’s fiscal stability becomes increasingly tenuous, our families need to know that our government will not leave them high and dry."
Ohio Democratic challengers Steve Black (OH-02), John Boccieri (OH-16), Mike Carroll (OH-04), Steve Driehaus (OH-01), Bill Connor (OH-07), Mary Jo Kilroy (OH-15), Bill O'Neill (OH-14), and Victoria Wulsin (OH-02) are all on the list of nominees for the Democracy for America "Grass Roots All-Star 2008" prize. Visitors to the DFA site can vote for up to three nominees. Three finalists will be elected, and a second round of voting will determine the winner. Finalists and the winner each get a $2,000 direct contribution from Democracy for America. The winner also gets a national fund raising email message from DFA Chair Jim Dean asking our 675,000 members to support the campaign, and the DFA Training Academy will come to the winner's state to train DFA members and encourage members to work on the campaign.
Readers should go over to the DFA site right now and vote for your favorite challengers!
Items of interest from the People's House contests:
OH-01: Key Endorsement for Driehaus - Local-48 of the International Association of Firefighters, which has endorsed Rep. Steve Chabot (R-Westwood) for the last several elections, gave the nod to challenger State Rep. Steve Driehaus (D-Price Hill) on Friday. Chabot's recent votes on collective bargaining were the biggest reason for the switch.
OH-02: Schmidt Gets Big Endorsement; Two Televised Democratic Debates on Tap; Black (D) Campaign Manager Profiled; "Wulsin Chick" on YouTube - The endorsement of Rep. Jean Schmidt (R-Loveland) by the Hamilton County GOP (by a wide margin) on Friday night is a huge blow to the hopes of challengers Phil Heimlich and Tom Brinkman. Blogger Bill Sloat reports that two televised Democratic joint appearances/debates are being discussed for next month, and writes a nice profile of Dan Herkert, campaign manager for Steve Black (D-Indian Hill). Ann Driscoll, a supporter of challenger Victoria Wulsin (D-Indian Hill), sings her praises in a YouTube video that is getting lots of play:
OH-03: Turner (R) Earmarks Benefit Campaign Donors - The blog Daytonology has an excellent post up relating earmarks by Rep. Mike Turner (R-Centerville) for the Austin Road Interchange highway project to Turner campaign donors in the real estate and development fields who stand to gain big benefits. Hat-tip to blogger/candidate David Esrati (D-Dayton).
OH-07: Key Endorsement for Hood; Neuhardt Names Campaign Manager - One of Ohio's most prominent conservative organizations, Family First Pac, has endorsed former state legislator Ron Hood (R-Ashville), who is mounting a serious grass-roots challenge to hand-picked successor State Sen. Steve Austria (R-Beavercreek). Sharen Neuhardt (D-Yellow Springs) has announced that Jim Alexee, currently the Finance Director for the Ohio Democratic Party, will be her campaign manager.
OH-08: Von Stein Online - The activist candidate Nick von Stein (D-Hamilton) has a campaign web site up. A nice biography (with photos) details the Hamilton native's U.S. Air Force service, political science education, and prior work on political campaigns and social issues. He is currently working on a Masters in Political Science at Miami University.
OH-10: New Cimperman TV Ad - Another clever attack ad by challenger Councilman Joe Cimperman (D-Cleveland) about Rep. Dennis Kucinich's presidential campaign, this time with professional actors and good production values:
OH-15: Business Leaders Flock to Stivers - State Sen. Steve Stivers (R-Upper Arlington) was picked by a whopping 73% of Ohio CEOs and business leaders in a poll taken earlier this month, compared to 9% for County Commissioner Mary Jo Kilroy (D-Columbus), who enjoys the support of labor groups.
OH-16: Miller Gains Conservative Group's Endorsement - The Family First Pac endorsed County Commissioner Matt Miller (R-Ashland) over State Sen. Kirk Schuring (R-North Canton) last Friday. Miller is running against establishment-preferred Schuring from the right.
Fred Thompson (R-VA), whose campaign probably peaked before he officially entered the race (since he never lived up to the hype after he got in), is out. The generally lackluster campaigner got 16% of the vote in South Carolina on Saturday, third behind McCain and Huckabee.
I suspect that Thompson's departure probably helps Mitt Romney the most, since Thompson was very socially conservative but did not appeal primarily to Christian evangelicals, although some of his followers may latch onto Mike Huckabee as the last Southerner in the race.
Paul Hackett campaigned with Rosemary Palmer (D-Cleveland) in the HopeMobile this weekend, enduring the freezing cold weather, talking about how we need "a little bit of adult leadership and responsibility:"
Big doings on the Congressional campaign trail:
OH-02: News Blizzard - Steve Black (D) thanked Victoria Wulsin (D) via a faxed note for engaging in an impromptu debate at the Anderson/Newtown Democratic Club meeting last evening, but renewed his demand for additional debates in all the other counties; SOTENI International, a non-profit founded and led by Wulsin that helps children with AIDS in Kenya, has issued a press release protesting an item in the Cincinnati-based web site "The Whistleblower Newswire" which portrays her as living a lavish lifestyle, and asserting that the organization is legit and Wulsin was not paid a salary by the organization, only travel expenses -- Bill Sloat has an item up explaining that Wulsin had mistakenly reported the value of her services as "salary" from SOTENI but has now revised her financial disclosure; Matt at WMD has reported on internal polling by Rep. Jean Schmidt (R) showing her with a commanding lead over challengers Phil Heimlich (R) and State Rep. Joe Brinkman (R):
OH-10: Big Endorsement for Cimperman; Kucinich Agrees to Debate; Hackett Stumps for Palmer - Cleveland Mayor Frank Jackson (D) has endorsed challenger Councilman Joe Cimperman (D), a huge boost for the candidate. The same news story reports that Rep. Dennis Kucinich (D) has agreed to debate all four of his challengers in an event to be sponsored by the City Club but held at the Crowne Plaza ballroom on February 19th. Iraq veteran and former U.S. Senate candidate Paul Hackett will campaign for Rosemary Palmer (D) at the opening of her office at 15732 Lorain Avenue tonight at 7:00 p.m., and again tomorrow aboard the HopeMobile with stops at a house party and a meeting with voters at Cleveland’s West Side Market at noon.
OH-15 & OH-16: DCCC Puts Races on "Red to Blue" List - The campaigns of County Commissioner Mary Jo Kilroy (D) and State Sen. John Boccieri (D) are included in a short list of seven open seat races and three special elections that will receive DCCC assistance under their "Red to Blue Program." From a post at DailyKos.com by DCCC Chair Chris Van Hollen:
As you know, these are strong examples of people-powered Democrats who have performed very well in the early stages of their campaigns. Their success is due not only to their message of change but all of your hard work. The energy and resources that the local and national Netroots have devoted to these candidates has been essential in providing their campaigns this exceptional early momentum. This is the earliest the DCCC’s Red to Blue program has been implemented in an election cycle.
The Red to Blue Program will introduce them to Democratic donors to help expand the fundraising base for their campaigns. It will give them the structural and financial edge they need to be even more competitive this year. A round of candidates challenging Republican incumbents will be announced next month.
OH-18: Schedule for RENEW OHIO-18 economic conferences Rep. Zack Space (D) is sponsoring these events to "develop a new economic blueprint for Southeastern Ohio":
January 25: RENEW OHIO-18 Ohio Kickoff, Zanesville, OH
February 29: Broadband Working Group Meeting, New Philadelphia, OH
March 21: Agriculture Working Group Meeting, Coshocton, OH
April 11: Alternative Energy Working Group Meeting, Nelsonville, OH
April 25: Healthcare Working Group Meeting, Chillicothe, OH
May 23: Summit, Zanesville, OH
Last night I was contacted by a Franklin County Democrat who reports that many people involved with the party are furious about the heavy-handed role of State Rep. Ted Celeste (D-Grandview) in last night's endorsement vote by the Franklin County Democratic Party Executive Committee in favor of first-time candidate Nancy Garland (D-New Albany) over repeat candidate Bev Campbell (D-Gahanna), who nearly won the seat in 2006.
The endorsement vote came after what was reported to have been a lengthy and contentious discussion. Campbell had little party support last time around, particularly early in the race, yet came within 364 votes out of about 60,000 after an official recount. Garland, Executive Director of the Ohio Physical Therapy Association, has extensive experience as a lobbyist but has not previously run for public office. There are points to be made for each candidate, but Campbell supporters are angry both that Garland was specifically recruited at the eleventh hour by Celeste, who has ambitions to run for House Speaker if the Democrats take control of the chamber and is seen as lining up supporters through his recruitment of candidates, and that he appears to have heavily influenced the vote by getting County Party Executive Director Zach Manifold to distribute a message in support of Garland to executive committee members prior to the vote.
Ohio Daily Blog has obtained a copy of Celeste's message, as well as a message in support of Campbell that Manifold was later asked to distribute -- but apparently did not. Celeste emailed Manifold to say that he's been asked why he supports Garland over Campbell and relates his concerns that Campbell "did not file a campaign finance report [last summer] showing she had raised any money since the last campaign" and that he "was looking for someone who could raise money, had good political experience and could wage a tough door to door campaign." He attached literature to his message from the Garland campaign "that should give you a good feel for why I feel she has a grasp of what it will take to win." [I did not receive the attachments.] Celeste then goes on to point out Garland's "extensive experience on Capitol Hill and at the Statehouse," the importance of Garland's expertise in health care as being "one of our major issues," her fund-raising capability, and her contacts around the state and nation as "important ingredients to a winning effort." Celeste adds that Garland "has put together a campaign group ready to host house parties, have fundraisers and go door to door." However, he concludes by noting that Garland "feels that the endorsement of the Franklin County Democratic Party is an important first step to her victory in November and I feel she will do well in the screening process" and "I know that she is committed to running and winning with that endorsement," remarks that imply that the endorsement may be necessary to keep Garland in the race. He ends by asking Manifold to distribute the message to committee members, which Manfold did, with the comment that Celeste asked him to do so.
An area Democrat who said that she was undecided on the primary race wrote to Manifold to question the fairness of Celeste's letter being distributed by a high-ranking party official, which "seems a bit like stacking the deck." Manifold replied that Celeste's "email wasn't working," a dubious claim on the face of it since Celeste sent email to Manifold, and "I only sent it out because the screening committee unanimously endorsed Garland yesterday," which doesn't appear to address the concern at all. That individual subsequently sent a letter in support of Campbell to Manifold with the request to distribute it, "in fairness to both sides," which reportedly was not done. This letter asks the committee to refrain from making an endorsement and points out Campbell's close race in 2006 without substantial support and despite being outspent by 10 to 1; that no Democrat before Campbell had captured more than 43% of the votes in this district; that Campbell has been active in a lengthy list of community groups and charities and has "visited nearly every church, synagogue and mosque, school, firehouse, police station, and business owner" in the district; that Campbell can connect with the voters and gain their trust better than "a career lobbyist;" and that Campbell is supported or endorsed by a long list of local and national political figures (including Sen. Joe Biden, former Congressman Bob Shamansky,
Treasurer Ed Leonard [see 2nd Update], Commissioner Mary Jo Kilroy, and Charleta Tavares), labor unions (including UAW, SEIU, and teachers unions), and advocacy groups (including the Sierra Club, Veterans & Military Families for Progress, and the Stonewall Democrats).
Contested primaries are a difficult proposition for a party under any circumstances, since they consume resources needed for the general election and (especially if negative) can generate animosity and division in the party base. However, primaries can play a positive role (as the author of the pro-Campbell note points out) by "invigorat[ing] the electorate and the party, test[ing] the candidates, and creat[ing] an opportunity to get all the information on the table." I'm very concerned about how this endorsement vote was handled, as tending to reduce the positives and increase the negatives (specifically by inflaming negative sentiments in the race), which is what we don't want. I have left telephone messages for Zach Manifold and Ted Celeste to ask for comments on this matter, and I have emailed the author of the pro-Campbell letter to get her comments as well, so I will update this story as appropriate.
UPDATES: Ted Celeste and Zach Monifold responded to my requests for comment -- continue reading after the break.
This is a key race as the Democrats seek to take control of the Ohio House of Representatives. Community activist Matt Patten is a dedicated progressive and deserves our support.
Come on out and meet the candidate at a fundraiser on January 24, 2008 from 5:00 to 8:00 pm at Tony K's, 841 W. Bagley Rd., Berea, OH 44017 - 440-234-9700.
Some items of note:
OH-02: Black (D) Blasts Wulsin (D) Over Lack of "Substance" on Web Site - In a fund-raising email, Steve Black (D-Indian Hill) takes Vic Wulsin (D-Indian Hill) to task for having relatively few and brief issue statements on her campaign site. The email sets out a side-by-side comparison of her four brief statements with the ten lengthy disquisitions available on Black's site. It's a clever attack, but is it fair? To some extent picking which issues to address and at what length is a matter of style, not substance.
OH-03: New Mitakides (D) Site? - I've been listing JaneMitakides.com as the web site for candidate Jane Mitakides (D-Dayton), but it is really just an online resume. However, she used Jane04.com as her campaign site in the 2004 race, and I see that Jane08.com has been reserved.
OH-07: Austria (R) Asserts Kids in Photo Are Real - A truly baffling comment appears on the campaign site for State Sen. Steve Austria (R-Beavercreek). Under a typical posed, smiling family portrait is a caption that identifies the candidate and his spouse and their three children - and then states that "they are not hired talent - they really are our family!"
OH-08: The Scoop on Nick von Stein (D) - I heard candidate Nick von Stein (D-Mason) introduce himself to the group at RootsCamp but did not get a chance to speak to him individually. However, I just tumbled across a mini-bio at the web site for America Votes:
Since coming to America Votes in April 2006 Nick has assisted the implementation of the southwest regional field plan, which includes mobilization of supporters, door-to-door canvassing and volunteer recruitment.
Pretty funny video clip, with challenger and city council member Joe Cimperman (D-Cleveland) visiting the office of Rep. Dennis Kucinich (D-Cleveland) in pursuit of the well-traveled incumbent:
Of course, it isn't fair to check a legislator's office just once and use it to suggest that he's MIA. If people went to Cimperman's office while he was filming this video, they wouldn't have found the councilman in, right? Still, pretty good visual.
Meanwhile, John Kraushaar writes on The Politico today about both Kucinich and GOP longshot Rep. Ron Paul (R-TX) facing stiff primary challenges at home. Kraushaar reports that after the New Hampshire primary, Cimperman showed up at Kucinich’s front door with kielbasa, Polish turnovers, a “Welcome Home” fruit basket, and a map. Here's a quote from Kucinich's political advisor, John Sweeney:
“This is the most serious challenge he’s had since he’s been running. This is going to be a tough race. Cimperman’s been in the business for a while, and he knows what he’s doing. We are not taking this lightly.”
Cimperman has reportedly raised $226,000 in the last month alone.
UPDATE: Unbelievable. Mark Naymik reports on Openers that Kucinich responded to the video by requesting a Department of Homeland Security investigation of Cimperman over his use of the video camera in a federal building.
How. Totally. Childish.
Big doings in local races:
Franklin: Redfern Endorses O'Grady - “Like the Franklin County Democratic Party, I want to announce my support for John O’Grady in the Franklin County Commissioners race," says ODP chair State Rep. Chris Redfern (D-Catawba Island). "John O’Grady has been a good and loyal friend to me and to the Ohio Democratic Party. John O’Grady will work to bring good paying jobs to central Ohio, and I am pleased to announce my support for his campaign.” O'Grady faces former judge and city council member Cindy Lazarus (D) in a hotly contested primary.
Mahoning: De Souza Writes on County Races - The Youngstown Vindicator's eminent political observer Bertram de Souza wrote a piece over the weekend about Cafaro Co. connections to some county races, and how the expected "bloodbath" in the wake of an epic county struggle over relocating the Jobs and Family Services Agency didn't materialize. Nevertheless, the struggle has echoes in the primary between County Treasurer and local Dem chair Lisa Antonini (D-Austintown) and attorney John Schultz (D). County Commissioner candidate Eric Ungaro (D-Poland), son of a former Youngstown mayor, submitted a comment to the online edition responding to the piece.
Columbiana: Sheriff Drops Out of Race - Sheriff David L. Smith (R-East Liverpool), facing trial on a drunk driving charge between now and the primary, has canceled his bid for re-election. Smith was stopped in Guernsey County last October while driving an unmarked cruiser and a urine test showed twice the legal level of alcohol. Anticipating this eventuality, there are three GOP challengers in the race (former deputy sheriff Jerry Herbert (R-New Waterford), former deputy sheriff Daniel "Skip" McLean III (R-Yellow Creek Twp), and police chief Ray Stone (R-Perry Twp)). Police chief John Soldano (D-Leetonia) will face the winner.
Clermont: GOP Commissioner Candidate Injured in Ski Accident - The Cincinnati Enquirer reports that Miami Township Trustee and county commissioner candidate Ed Humphrey (R) fell while skiing in Michigan on Tuesday. He broke three ribs and injured the tips of seven vertebrae in his back. However, although incapacitated and lying in the hospital now, he is determined to continue his primary battle against incumbent Mary Walker (R) and Batavia Township Trustee Archie Wilson (R). There is no Democrat in this race.
Summit: Pry Online - County executive Russell Pry (D) has announced his new campaign web site. He faces recent mayoral contender Joe Finley (D) in a primary, and the winner will be opposed by Municipal Court Clerk Jim Laria (R).
Retired U.S. Air Force Lt. Col. John Mitchel (R-Beavercreek), now running for the seat of retiring Rep. Dave Hobson (R-Springfield) and a veteran of past campaigns for Governor and Congress, charges that opponent State Sen. Steve Austria (R-Beavercreek) and his spouse Eileen are co-conspirators in a scheme to steer no-bid contracts to campaign contributors of Hobson, who supports Steve Austria in the race and has paid Eileen Austria large consulting fees. Mitchel compares the scheme to the steering of federal contracts by Rep. Randy "Duke" Cunningham (R-CA) that resulted in his resignation from Congress in November 2005 and guilty plea to federal conspiracy charges. Cunningham is serving an eight year prison sentence.
In an email to Greene County officials, following up on his request for a meeting to discuss requests for information on the matter, Mitchel describes his allegations this way:
Former California Congressman Randy "Duke" Cunningham is in federal prison for steering no-bid contracts toward his campaign contributors. Based on remarks spoken to me by Ms. [Marilyn] Reid, [the Greene County GOP chair who is running for county commissioner,] I am alleging that is exactly what occurred with the BRAC Initiative Agreement. There is compelling evidence that Dave Hobson and other elected officials, including Steve Austria as well as Mrs. Austria, who both sit on the Dayton Development Coalition Wright-Patt 2010 Advisory Committee, intervened to influence the award of no-bid contracts to The PMA and Greentree Groups. Please note that documents disclosed on the FEC website show that employees from PMA and Greentree donated over $50,000 to "Hobson for Congress" prior to, during and since the period of performance (PoP) of the BRAC Initiative Agreement. Don't hesitate to call if you have any questions prior to our meeting on the 24th.
On the telephone yesterday, Mitchel further explained his accusation. Steve and Eileen Austria sit on the referenced advisory committee along with Sam Greenwood of the Greentree Group. They were instrumental in causing money transferred by Greene County to the Dayton Development Corporation to be used to award a large no-bid contract to Greentree Group, purportedly to assist in an effort to keep Wright Patterson Air Force Base open during the BRAC (Base Realignment and Closure) process. Mitchel contends, however, that the base was in no real danger of closing, so the transactions in reality amounted to no more than an enormous transfer of public wealth to private hands, and in any event the purpose of the contract was lobbying and that is not the business of Greentree, an IT firm. Greentree in turn awarded a $660,000 contract to PMA, which is in fact a lobbying firm. During the period for performance under these contracts, principals or employees of Greentree and PMA gave $50,000 in campaign contributions to Hobson. Eileen Austria was a district director for Hobson, and while so employed Hobson paid her $50,000 as a political consultant. Linking the transfers together, Mitchel sees an orchestrated chain of transactions that acted as a pipeline for public money that ultimately wound up in the hands of Eileen Austria.
Latest reported in the Akron Beacon Journal: State Sen. Kevin Coughlin (R-Cuyahoga Falls) is challenging the nominating petitions of 64 Republican central committee candidates, presumably ones aligned with foe Alex Arshinkoff. 600 people filed for 475 seats, and Coughlin claims that 315 filings represent supporters of his bid to oust Arshinkoff, including 170 petitions filed directly by Coughlin. However, as many as 18 of his supporters have already been tossed off the ballot and hearings are pending for as many more. He is now trying to improve his odds by getting Arshinkoff supporters bounced, claiming (credibly, it appears) that BOE employees examined the petitions of Coughlin supporters more closely than those of Arshinkoff supporters.
Coughlin requested hearings on a number of his challenges and also for a challenge regarding GOP elections board director Bryan Williams, running for the GOP State Central Committee, who Coughlin claims got signatures for his petition from elections board employees during business hours. In a related controversy, Williams is standing by his decision to transfer a BOE employee, Scott Sigel, who says that he learned of "a few problems" in his position as GOP finance examiner. Williams accuses Sigel of publicizing his "personal political crusade" to have his boss fired or replaced. Sigel calls William's move "punishment" and an "abuse of power." The matter will go to the entire board for review.
The fight between Coughlin and his camp and Arshinkoff and his allies will presumably escalate over the next two months as we move toward the vote by the GOP central committee on county party leadership, which will occur during the first week of May.
More tidbits from working on the candidates list:
OH-07: Web Sites Up; Fun Facts - New campaign sites are up for attorney Sharen Neuhardt (D-Yellow Springs) and former state legislator Ron Hood (R-Ashville). This article from the Lancaster Eagle Gazette has some fun factoids about the crowded field, such as that former county health inspector Tom Scrivens (D-Xenia) was deputy campaign manager during John Glenn's 1984 bid for president, former Libertarian candidate Jack Null (D-Fairborn) served 20 years in the U.S. Army, and Dr. Richard Wyderski (D-Beavercreek) is firmly committed to single-payer health care: "A single-payer system is the most (practical) way to make sure that everyone has health care coverage," he said. "Everyone is in, and no one is out."
OH-08: Meier Drops Out - 2006 candidate Morton Meier (D) has dropped out of the race, leaving political activist and USAF veteran Nick von Stein (D-Mason) as the only opponent to Rep. John Boehner (R-West Chester).
OH-12: New Dagres Site - Aaron Dagres (D) had been using his Facebook page as a campaign site, but now he has his own domain.
First-term State Rep. Eugene Miller (D-Cleveland) faces a primary challenge from Freddie Moore (D-Cleveland), but it appears from Cuyahoga County Board of Elections records that the only GOP candidate Susan Capello (R-Cleveland) has withdrawn her nominating petitions.
Just a few quick items of interest as I work on refining the candidates list:
OH-07: Woolever (D) Wins IBEW Endorsement - Restaurant owner Dave Woolever (D-Stoutsville), a former IBEW member, has earned the endorsement of IBEW Local 1466, based in Columbus. From the presser:
"... Of all the candidates for the Democratic nomination in the seventh district of Ohio, I know what the working men and women of Ohio face in this current job climate," Woolever said. "I have suffered job loss when a job I held was outsourced to Mexico. I was a member of the IBEW Local 2331 when I worked in my next job. When the signs were showing that they would close due to outsourcing, I decided that my best course of action was to open a small business in the community. Not long after, that plan closed and jobs were lost to both China and India
“I will stand shoulder to shoulder with the people who are the heart and soul of Ohio, the working men and women. I will work to change the direction of trade agreements that have devastated jobs here in Ohio. I will work to make sure that a good day’s work brings a good day’s pay to those who need it the most. ...”
OH-12: Renaissance Candidate - I'm really impressed with the variety of interests and accomplishments revealed on the bio page of candidate David W. Robinson (D). He graduated cum laude from OSU with an undergraduate degree in accounting and has a master’s degree in Theological Studies from The Chicago Theological Seminary and a Ph.D. in theology and psychology from Emory University. He organized and carried out a 4,700-mile cross-country fund-raising bicycle ride for Alzheimer's research, he taught English in Taiwan for a year, and recently he was a Presenter for Al Gore’s Climate Project initiative and has given numerous presentations on global warming. His is now a vice president for Marcy Enterprises, a Columbus-based adhesive tape manufacturer.
OH-11: Saffold Withdraws Shaker Heights businessman Robert Saffold (R) has withdrawn his nominating petitions, leaving only Thomas Pekerak (R) to oppose Rep. Stephanie Tubbs Jones (D-Cleveland).
OH-15: Three GOP Challengers Disqualified - State Sen. Steve Stivers (R-Upper Arlington) still faces a primary challenge from OSU economics professor Robert Wagner (R), but additional challengers Charles Chope, John Diamond, and perennial candidate Ralph Applegate were all tossed off the ballot.
Senator Sherrod Brown (D-Avon) will be in Cincinnati tomorrow and will be holding an informal meet and greet at Crowley's, 958 Pavilion Street in Mt. Adams, at 7:00 PM. If you’d like to meet Senator Brown here's your chance. All are welcome.
Click here for a map.
This is great to see. Republicans hold all county offices in Clermont County and there hasn't been a Democratic county commissioner there in 28 years, but current county commissioner Mary Walker (R) is being investigated by the Ohio Ethics Commission and faces criminal corruption charges. There are GOP primary challengers attempting to block Walker's bid for re-election, but the county Democratic Party is capitalizing on the disarray by fielding strong candidates and making a serious run at both commissioner seats up for election, clerk of courts, and county recorder. As reported in the Enquirer last weekend:
For the first time in two decades, Democrats have launched a major assault on Republicans entrenched in positions of power in Clermont County.
"It's the strongest and largest slate of candidates probably in 16 to 18 years," said Gregg Conrad, a Pierce Township trustee who met Friday's filing deadline to run as a Democrat for clerk of Common Pleas Court. ...
The rallying cry of many Democrats, regardless of the office sought, is this: "Mary Walker."
Milford Democrat Theresa Conover filed last month to run for Walker's seat in the November election, saying "people are tired of the perceived corruption."
Even members of her own party want to distance themselves from Walker, who has been a commissioner since 2001.
Competing in the GOP primary against Walker will be Batavia Township Trustee Archie Wilson, Miami Township Trustee Ed Humphrey and former Bethel Councilman Melvin Dean. "I think we need to replace the current commissioner for obvious reasons," Dean said after filing Friday.
It is only by a fluke that I’m editing the 100th Carnival of Ohio Politics this week. But please, don’t let a fluke get in the way of your submitting - first timer or veteran - to this week’s edition of the Carnival.
Send up to three links to blog posts you’ve written about Ohio and politics by tomorrow night, Tuesday, 1/15, 9pm to ohiopolcarnival AT gmail DOT com and voila - you’ve made Ohio political blog history.
Please feel free to spread the word and keep the posts coming.
100 posts in the 100th edition is the goal.
Join Rosemary Palmer and special guest, Paul Hackett, as we open the new Palmer for Congress storefront. Food, drink, speeches, and lots of fun. Plus, see the "HopeMobile" up close!
When: Friday, January 18th 2008, 7:00 to 10:00 p.m.
Where: Rosemary Palmer for Congress Campaign HQ
15732 Lorain Blvd.
Cleveland, OH 44111
I am pressed for time but I want to highlight this short interview with Sen. Sherrod Brown (D-Avon) by David Skolnick in the Youngstown Vindicator. The headline and emphasis of the story is about the Democrats' lack of success in forcing an end to the war in Iraq. Brown is candid about the failure of the Democrats' strategy to date and doesn't think the chances of getting troops withdrawn during the rest of the session are great (although they will keep trying). I liked this bit:
The Bush administration and its supporters tell the public the United States can’t pull out of Iraq when there are problems because the country can’t govern itself, Brown said. When there is some stability in Iraq, the administration and its supporters say the policy is working and the United States has to stay there, he added.
“Look at the ludicrousness of the argument,” he said.
Brown also talks about his disappointment about not getting the SCHIP program expanded, a matter that will be taken up again this summer.
However, the part of the article that really caught my attention was about the presidential race:
As for the Democratic presidential race, Brown said he is remaining neutral — at least for now.
Brown had high praise for ex-U.S. Sen. John Edwards, who is lagging behind U.S. Sens. Barack Obama and Hillary Rodham Clinton in polls.
Brown likes Edwards' "populist message," his concern about free-trade policies, and his stand against big oil and pharmaceutical companies.
"I’d like to see Edwards’ message more from Obama and Clinton," he said.
Brown said he met with Clinton last month for an hour to discuss how to win Ohio. Clinton campaigned for Brown in his successful 2006 Senate campaign.
The Akron Beacon Journal reports that the Summit County Board of Elections has disqualified two candidates for the Ohio House of Representatives due to problems with nominating petitions.
In the 44th District, State Rep. Vernon Sykes (D-Akron) will be unopposed in this election because he has no primary challenger and his only GOP adversary, Adrian Sims (R), was removed from the ballot. The Ohio Republican Party has made much of fielding a candidate in every House district, so this is a setback for them on that front.
Freshly appointed State Rep. John Otterman (D-Akron) still had a Republican opponent in Joe Fazek (R), but sole primary opponent Brian Bardwell (D) has been taken off the ballot.